Totally skipped RE5 but Resident Evil 4 scared me shitless, especially the first time a chainsaw-wielding fat dude with a burlap sack on his head chased me through a creepy village and slashed through walls to get to me. I was not prepared for that; I really tried to not play that game at night. Dead Space as well.
What’s the scariest game you’ve ever played?
P.S. I refuse to play Amnesia: Dark Descent. I like sleeping. Do you? You can definitely find out here.